Why Emotional Connection Isn’t Enough in Marriage

Emotional vs Sexual Needs: The Marriage Reciprocity Gap

Why treating emotional connection as non-negotiable while dismissing sexual needs as “pressure” creates an unsustainable double standard that damages even the healthiest marriages. This article explores why women must step up sexually if they expect men to step up emotionally, and how responsive desire, intentional intimacy, and mutual reciprocity can transform struggling relationships.

First, a quick disclaimer: This article isn’t for anyone dealing with abuse, coercion, or trauma. Here I’m talking only to women in generally loving marriages with good men.

We have no problem telling men they need to ‘step up’ emotionally. We insist that emotional connection is non-negotiable in marriage, and if they won’t provide it, they’re failing as a partner. And this is true. Emotional connection does matter and it’s not optional in a healthy marriage.

But if we expect him to step up emotionally, we shouldn’t be surprised when he asks us to step up sexually.

We cannot build a marriage in which our needs are considered “valid boundaries” while his are dismissed as “pressure” or “entitlement.”

Why Sexual Connection Is a Legitimate Marriage Need

So, if we’re asking good men to step up emotionally, we must bravely ask ourselves: Why and how do we need to step up when it comes to physical intimacy?

First, we need to acknowledge that a functional marriage requires more than emotional connection. It requires sexual connection too.

When we agreed to monogamy, we implicitly agreed to make sexual connection available to our spouse. Not no matter what, but generally speaking, that’s the commitment. Furthermore, sex is a legitimate relationship need, as valid as trust, conversation, or emotional connection. It’s a vital aspect of marriage that should be nurtured, given space, and prioritized, just like emotional connection.

This isn’t something that comes easily to most women. As a result, it’s often left to our husbands to keep the physical side of our marriages alive. It’s up to them to raise the topic, initiate, and try to convince us that a sexually fulfilling life is something to pursue and embrace, rather than fear or avoid.

Isn’t it fair, then, for them to ask us to contribute positively to this side of our marriage, even when it doesn’t come naturally to us?

Of course it is.

The Double Standard: Why Men’s Sexual Needs Are Dismissed as Pressure

But culturally, we don’t treat these two vital aspects of marriage the same way.

A woman’s insistence on deeper emotional connection in her marriage is typically seen as healthy and empowered; boundary-setting and a sign of emotional maturity. But when a husband insists that sexual connection matters too; that sex should be part of a healthy marriage… suddenly he’s out of line. Instead of viewing this normal, natural desire as reasonable and healthy, we dismiss it as pressure, entitlement, or a failure to respect boundaries.

Who decided that emotional connection trumps sexual connection on every level? That it must come first, and that’s that?

Yes, emotional connection matters. But it’s only half the story.

You can’t build the deep emotional connection you crave while starving your partner of the physical connection they need. That’s an impossible ask.

Why Waiting for Emotional Connection Before Sex Doesn’t Work

We’ve been taught that sex will naturally follow once some undefined level of emotional connection has been achieved. But that’s simply not how it works. These forces operate together. The masculine and the feminine. They both feed into one another to create something greater than the sum of their parts.

And yet, I often hear women say, “I’d be okay with never having sex again”, as if that’s just something her husband needs to accept with grace.

But imagine if he said, “I’d be okay with never having a deep conversation again.”

We’d laugh and shake our heads in disbelief. “Then why on earth did you marry a woman!?”

Because we all understand that refusing emotional connection for months or years is cruel, unreasonable, and tantamount to abandonment.

But somehow, long-term sexual withdrawal is considered a ‘boundary’ our husbands are supposed to respect without complaint. And if they even dare try to discuss it, or express disappointment, they’re often accused of being coercive; making rational conversation impossible.

How Sexual Rejection Leads to Resentment in Marriage

And when something this important can’t be discussed without tension, resentment and withdrawal are inevitable.

In fact, I often hear women in decades-long sexless marriages say, “He’s so angry! That’s the problem here!”

OK but, hang on. If my husband dismissed my emotional needs for days, let alone months, I’d eventually become pretty angry too. His anger may well be the result of years of neglect, not the cause of it. And the irony is, we know exactly what that resentment feels like.

When we say, “If I didn’t initiate conversations, we’d never talk about anything important”, that’s exactly what he’s feeling: “If I didn’t pursue sex, it wouldn’t ever happen.”

And they’re often right, walking a tightrope between advocating for legitimate needs and coming across as entitled.

This is why men so desperately want their wives to initiate, at least occasionally. Not because they’re lazy, but because our initiation communicates: “I love you, I understand this matters to you, and I’m with you.”

If we expect men to grow where it’s hard for them, we must be willing to grow where it’s hard for us too.

Ladies, this is our work.

3 Ways Women Can Step Up Sexually in Marriage

First: Address your barriers head-on.

Whether it’s past experiences requiring therapy, hormonal imbalances needing medical attention, or shame and body image struggles. Whatever it is, that’s your work to do.

Second: Understand responsive desire.

You might not spontaneously “feel like it” out of the blue, and that’s normal. But that means you’re responsible for becoming intentional about intimacy, rather than just waiting to “feel like it.”

Third: Initiate.

Be the one to suggest it. Be the one to pursue, at least on occasion. Take the weight of rejection off him and show him that he matters to you in the way it matters to him. Because that’s really all this is about.

And I’m not just saying any of this as a therapist. I’m saying it as a wife.

In my own marriage, I’ve seen how he becomes a deeper, more grounded man when he steps toward me emotionally. And when I step toward him sexually, it creates a closeness and joy that nothing else in our marriage can match.

There are no losers in this dynamic.

The Hidden Cost of Long-Term Sexless Marriages

And yet, when this spirit of reciprocity is absent, the cost to a marriage can be devastating, as I recently witnessed with a client who inspired this entire article.

A man in his 50s; the epitome of a true gentleman: sensitive and kind, honest, intelligent, compassionate, and committed to his own psychological work. He’s remained loyal to his wife and deeply engaged in their marriage.

Yet she hasn’t had sex with him in decades, despite his every effort to accommodate her needs. He’s not in therapy to change his wife, but to find support in accepting this hopeless situation.

It’s utterly heart-breaking to watch this strong, usually stoic man unravelling at the seams. The loneliness, frustration, and isolation he grapples with daily is something I wouldn’t wish on my worst enemy.

And I wish that this was an exceptional case, but sadly, it’s not.

He represents what is a massive, unspoken tragedy playing out in countless homes across the world. Good men. Truly good men. Being abandoned in their marriages while being told it’s their fault.

That has to change.

Jump to Comments

Recommended Reading About Intimacy in Marriage